A publication of the Centre for Advancing Journalism & Information Integrity, University of Melbourne

Environment

Thornbury sugar gums saved a year ago face the axe again

Two century-old trees in Thornbury could be cut down under a state fast-track rule that bypasses community objections. Darebin councillors are urging their officers to delay a decision and seek further advice on the health of the trees. Preeshita Shah reports.
Thornbury sugar gums saved a year ago face the axe again

Residents gathered beneath one of two century-old sugar gums at 148 Ballantyne Street, Thornbury, to meet council representatives on Friday. Photo by Preeshita Shah.

Story by Preeshita Shah
 

A year ago, Thornbury residents thought they had saved two century-old sugar gums from the axe, campaigning to persuade Darebin Council to refuse an application for their removal.

But the trees are threatened with the chop again, this time under a fast-track state process that gives councillors and residents no say, and “is so streamlined it doesn’t give council discretion”, Darebin chief executive Anne Howard told protesting residents at a meeting under the trees on Friday.

Residents who campaigned to save the trees at 148 Ballantyne Street learned on 12 November that a decision on the latest application was due within days, and that council officers had an arborist’s report rating the trees as high risk to a house that has not yet been built.

The property owner applied on 2 October under Clause 52.37 of the Victoria Planning Provisions, a rule the State Government added to Victoria’s planning system in September 2025 to protect and enhance tree canopy.

Applications under the rule can be fast-tracked through VicSmart, which gives councils 10 business days to decide. Neighbours are not notified, cannot object and cannot appeal. The decision rests with the council’s chief executive and planning officers, not elected councillors.

On Monday, councillors called an emergency meeting and voted unanimously to ask Howard to consider waiting at least two weeks before making a decision.

They also asked for a new, more detailed arborist assessment “on the basis of the lot as vacant land, noting there is no proposal for development at the site”.

“The CEO and council officers are working through implementation of council’s decision,” the council said in a statement to The Citizen.

Council officers refused the owner’s first application in September 2025, under the council’s tree protection law. The owner asked for a review, and the council commissioned a new arborist assessment, which was completed in September 2026 and shared with the owner.

That report, by Liam Kennedy of Gum & Maple Consulting, rates both trees as high risk. The high rating applies only to branches that could fall on a future double-storey house, as shown on a floor plan that was among the documents Kennedy reviewed.

He rated the risk as low for the power lines and people on the footpath. A falling branch on the future house represented a risk to the structure, but the consequences would be “significant for the future dwelling, not severe for persons in the dwelling due to ‘protection factors’ of the roof”, he determined.

In an update on its website on 12 November, the council said the report found the risk had escalated to high, “causing an unacceptable safety risk to residents”.

Residents argue that a house nobody has applied to build cannot justify removing the trees. But Howard told them on Friday it was reasonable to expect the block would be developed.

An assessment commissioned by the residents from Tree Dimensions in August 2025 rated the trees’ health as good and their risk to people as low.

A petition to save them gathered 881 signatures.

“These trees have been here for over 100 years, to then in 10 days suddenly decide they’re going to go,” one resident told Howard on Friday. “I think you need to push back and say we need more time.”

Council officers had raised the risk that the owner could appeal a refusal to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

“The risk to your reputation and community outrage is much higher if there’s not a good decision on this,” said Melanie Del Monaco, who speaks for the residents’ group Save Darebin’s Trees.

The owner, who bought the property at auction in May 2025, did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

“This is positive news for now, but we still need to save the trees,” Save Darebin’s Trees wrote on Instagram after Monday’s vote.

Members of the Save Darebin’s Trees group stand between the two sugar gums at 148 Ballantyne Street, Thornbury. The vacant block, now fenced, sits between the trees. Photo Supplied.

Members of the Save Darebin’s Trees group stand between the two sugar gums at 148 Ballantyne Street, Thornbury. The vacant block, now fenced, sits between the trees. Photo Supplied.

About The Citizen

THE CITIZEN is a publication of the Centre for Advancing Journalism & Information Integrity. It has several aims. Foremost, it is a teaching tool that showcases the work of the students in the University of Melbourne’s Master of Journalism and Master of International Journalism programs, giving them real-world experience in working for publication and to deadline. Find out more →